Orca 58 Quart Review: Camping Coolers

My Open Country is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a small commission at no cost to you.​

Orca 58 Quart Review

4.0/5

The ORCA 58-quart cooler is almost big enough to hide a body, but that’s not why it’s one of the best ways to keep your food and drinks cool this summer.

The ORCA 58-Quart cooler has some great features, including one of the best designs for insulation and durability even among the top brands in the industry. These factors, plus the easy handling to the amount of storage ratio, make this a really unique find in outdoor equipment.

Bottom Line: A solid cooler that will keep your food and drinks cold and fresh for days, perfect for your next camping, fishing or hunting trip.

Orca Hard Sided Classic Cooler White 58 Quart
Our Rating: 4.0

Key Features

  • Thick insulated walls, lid, and bottom made from a heavy-duty, roto-molded construction
  • Flexible handles make it easy to carry
  • Attached cargo net
  • 58-quart capacity and 18.5″ x 12.3″ x 13.375″ in size
  • Four colors to choose from
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Tight-fitting lid gasket and easy drainage spout

Overall Scores

Insulation 92%
Durability 83%
Ease of Use 55%
Portability 65%
Features 50%

What We Like

  • Probably the best insulation in the business
  • Can easily be carried by one person
  • Holds enough food to get stranded on a desert island
  • Heavy-duty and durable; can stand up to lots of abuse

What Are Our Gripes

  • The lid closes on you when you least expect it!
  • Listed price is a little more expensive than some models with the same capacity

Hands on Review

You can’t really know how something works until you get behind the wheel, kick the tires a little and take it for a test drive. Car metaphors aside, we put this cooler through its paces on a four-and-a-half day camping trip to determine if it was really as good as everyone was claiming.

With so much space in the cooler, we gathered a five-person crew and threw the cooler onto the back of a pickup truck to take to the woods.

Insulation

This was probably the easiest to predict. You could just tell by lifting the cooler and looking at it up close that it was going to be amazing at insulation. The walls are really thick; the lid fits like it has an airtight seal and it just looks like a cooler that is going to keep everything really cold (or hot if that’s what you need).

In this case, the cooler still had between 60% and 70% of the ice that was put into it on day one when we got it home. That means that after 96 hours, the food was still cold (although mostly gone) and the drinks were like they had been stored in a snow bank in Antarctica. The manufacturer specs say that it keeps things ice cold for 10 days, and we would agree with that.

Durability

Next up was durability. First of all, the construction of this cooler is really solid. The hinges are thick nylon and don’t look as if they are going to wear out anytime in the next dozen or so camping trips, even with everyone opening and closing it every fifteen minutes or so.

It sustained the bumpy ride up to the campsite in the back of a pickup truck, sliding from one end to the other occasionally. The handles don’t feel as if they are going to break when you pick it up, even when it’s full of 12-packs, steaks, hot dogs and everyone else we stuffed in there.

At first, it was a little tempting to complain because the hinges and handles are mostly nylon rather than plastic. However, as the trip went on, it was clear that this material was much stronger and more durable than plastic would have been. So, there’s really nothing to complain up with durability. 

Ease of Use

When it comes to ease of use, there is really only one thing to be aware of. You may remember the earlier complaint that the lid closes unexpectedly. This is a problem for three reasons. First, it comes down pretty hard, and if it was a little hand that was trapped under the lid when it came down, it would probably hurt.

Second, it’s a problem because it is really inconvenient. When you are trying to pull stuff out of the cooler, and you keep coming back to find it is closed, it is kind of irritating. We ended up holding the lid the first night when we pulled almost everything out trying to find the steaks (which were at the bottom of course)

Third, it’s loud when it comes down. If the rubber was sticking out a little more it would probably be okay, but it’s the plastic of the lid that sticks out the farthest, and it slaps the plastic of the lip. At night, if someone gets a bottle of water out and forgets to close it, it will wake you up if you’re a light sleeper.

However, as far as the rest of the factors that fall under “ease of use” – the drain works well and doesn’t leak and there’s nothing else to complain about at all.

View this post on Instagram

Essential Combinations #Orca | #OrcaCoolers | #OrcaCafe

A post shared by ORCA (@orcacoolers) on

Portability

This cooler is pretty big, and the walls are thick, but for some reason, this is still a really light cooler to carry. Plus, because of how much slack there is with the nylon handles, one person could easily carry it if they had to. There is a rubber grip on each handle so that the nylon doesn’t dig into your hand; it could be improved by adding wheels.

Features

When it comes to camping equipment these days, you can find all sorts of features, and even with coolers. There are coolers out there that have a phone charging station built-in, some that have water tanks with spouts outside the cooler to fill up and even coolers with lighting or speakers.

This one is pretty basic. The only real features are the two places where you can put a padlock if you want to lock up something in the cooler and the net attached to the side that will store a small amount of stuff.

Technical Specifications

Best UseCamping
Gear Capacity (L)58 liters
Gear Capacity (cu. in.)3,539 cubic inches
Material(s)Rotomold polyethylene
Dimensions18.5 x 12.3 x 13.375 inches
Weight32 lbs.

Limitations

The only limitations on this cooler are the fact that it gets pretty heavy when it is completely full of food and canned stuff. For the average person, this probably won’t be a problem. The average guy (or strong girl) can carry it himself if necessary, and it is quite comfortable with two people. For someone who doesn’t have much upper body strength, this might be a problem.

Best Applications

Probably the best applications for this cooler are guys and girls going on a camping trip, or families that don’t have really small kids that could get their fingers mashed when the lid comes down. It probably wouldn’t break them or anything, but it would definitely hurt.

Those with disabilities, the elderly or people who just don’t have the ability to lift and carry (one on each side) a range of 50 to 100 pounds should probably get something that has wheels and is more mobile.

View this post on Instagram

Wishin we were fishin

A post shared by ORCA (@orcacoolers) on

Value

You can’t say that this is an incredible value for the money, but it isn’t that bad. It depends upon what is important to you in a cooler. If you want insulation more than anything else and aren’t too concerned about additional features like phone charging stations, then this is definitely a good buy. It is definitely a good brand, and many camping experts laud it as one of their top choices for coolers. It’s worth the money you pay for it because it will last for a really long time.

Other Amazon Stores:   UK   |   CA

Other Versions & Accessories

There aren’t really any accessories for this unless you count the net attachment, which comes included. There are a few other options you have with this cooler.

First, you have a choice of four colors: an army green, pink, white and tan. It’s rumored that ORCA donates a portion of their profit to an organization based upon the color (pink = breast cancer awareness for example), but it isn’t listed on their website so it may not be true.

You also have several sizes to choose from if you don’t want to go with a 58-quart cooler. They have all of the following sizes available: 20 qt., 26 qt., 40 qt., 58 qt., 75 qt. and 140 qt.

Alternatives

BEST CAMPING COOLER

Canyon Cooler Outfitters 55 Quart

Canyon Cooler Outfitters 55

When it comes to insulation, both of these coolers are pretty amazing. As mentioned, the ORCA cooler lasted for 5 days on the test, and the manufacturer’s description says it will last for 10. The Canyon comes close here, and there is not much in it, but the Orca just gets the nod here. They are also really close on durability, but the Canyon wins it here again because it is a little tougher than the ORCA. In fact, Canyon offers a lifetime warranty on their cooler.

When it comes to ease of use, the Canyon is the clear winner here, because the lid stays open and will not close arbitrarily while you are getting stuff out like the ORCA does. But the ORCA cooler wins in portability because the Canyon has stiff plastic handles and it is easier for one person to carry the ORCA.

They are both about the same when it comes to features, with no major advantages over the other one. When it comes to value, the Canyon leaves the ORCA in the dust because not only is it the superior product; it also costs less than the ORCA – a lot less in fact. So, the winner here is the Canyon 55-quart, hands down.

Sharing is Caring

Share on facebook
Share on pinterest
Share on twitter
Share on reddit
Share on email
Orca 58 Quart
Orca Hard Sided Classic Cooler White 58 Quart
5/5
Probably the best insulation in the business, Can easily be carried by one person, Holds enough food to get stranded on a desert island, Heavy-duty and durable; can stand up to lots of abuse

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.